The main differences between fiber laser cleaners and carbon dioxide cleaners can be compared from the following aspects:
Working principle and material suitability:
Fiber laser cleaning machine: the use of fiber lasers, wavelength of 1064 nm, very suitable for metal processing, especially steel, aluminum, copper and other metal materials.
Carbon Dioxide Cleaners: Produces a beam of gas by exciting carbon dioxide molecules. The wavelength is usually between 9400 and 10600 nanometers, making it ideal for processing non-metallic materials such as fabrics, leather and other organic materials.
Electro-optic conversion efficiency:
Fiber laser cleaning machine: electro-optical conversion efficiency is high, up to 25% ~ 30%.
Carbon dioxide cleaning machine: electro-optical efficiency is low, between 10% and 20%.
Maintenance and Operating Costs:
Fiber Laser Cleaners: Low maintenance, lower cost due to higher efficiency and less maintenance.
CO2 Cleaners: Regular maintenance is required, and more frequent maintenance leads to higher costs.
Precision and cutting ability:
Fiber Laser Cleaner: Provides higher platform accuracy and finer cutting capabilities.
Carbon dioxide cleaning machine: low accuracy, suitable for thicker, lower precision cutting.
Initial Investment Cost and Lifetime:
Fiber laser cleaning machine: higher initial investment costs, but longer life, up to 100,000 hours.
Carbon dioxide washer: Low initial investment cost and short life, about 20,000 hours.
Metal absorption rate:
Fiber Laser Cleaner: The metal has a high absorption rate for the 1064 nanometer wavelength of the fiber laser, which is suitable for metal processing.
Carbon Dioxide Cleaner: Metals have poor absorption of the 10600 nm wavelength of CO2 laser.
Environmental protection and safety:
Fiber laser cleaning machine: more environmentally friendly, because no organic solvent volatilization is produced, no toxic and flammable solvents are involved.
Carbon dioxide cleaners: Although there is some environmental protection, in terms of safety, carbon dioxide lighters are usually larger and more dangerous than the same power light fiber lighters.
Price:
Fiber laser cleaners: more expensive, but high efficiency, high precision, long life, is the first choice for many industrial applications.
Carbon dioxide cleaning machine: relatively cheap, suitable for processing non-metallic materials, is an affordable choice.
In summary, fiber laser cleaners have advantages in metal processing, electro-optical conversion efficiency, maintenance cost, accuracy, life and environmental protection, while carbon dioxide cleaners have advantages in non-metallic material processing and cost. Which cleaning machine to choose needs to be decided based on the specific application needs and budget.
